Monday, June 30, 2008

Capitalism and Christianity?

Well the election year is in full swing and one of the things that I’ve promised myself is that on this blog I wouldn’t do politics. Last Sunday, however, I had a revelation about some things during a sermon on the Good Samaritan.

As an unashamed Christian and conservative, I’ve always struggled with, on one hand, the social justice work that Christ calls me to, and on the other hand, my fiscally conservative beliefs. As a very strict Republican on the economy, I believe in less welfare, less government dependence, less taxes, and less government handouts. And all of that is fine. I’m not sure that God really endorses one kind of economic system over another. There are benefits and downsides to all kinds of economies.

But to me it always seemed like a paradox to say to myself, “Self, you are called to have compassion on the poor and the widows and the homeless” but at the same time to say “Self, a free market economy inside a welfare free society is the way to go. There will always be poor, but that’s ok since the poor bring it upon themselves.” How could these two attitudes go hand in hand? Could a true Christian really believe in capitalism?

Here’s what I’ve learned sitting through that sermon. It’s perfectly okay to be a Christian and a capitalist. It’s also okay to be a Christian and a socialist, although I don’t think any of us think that is a good way to do things. Here’s the catch: those to the right calling for a less regulated economy need to be like the Good Samaritans. Those calling for less welfare and federal aid need to be the on the front lines doing social work and helping the poor and clothing the homeless. Those Libertarians and Republicans alike calling for a smaller and weaker government need to take things into our own hands and not shirk the responsibility that all Americans as private citizens and Christians have as citizens of the City of God to care for the needy. Those who complain about social welfare at the polls need to be the first ones to volunteer for the soup kitchen. Now I’m not talking about engaging in government programs. I speak of engaging as private citizens. Let me give you a few reasons why this should be so.

First and foremost, it is the attitude of all regenerate and true Christians to help the needy. This is enough to persuade us all. Secondly, doing so increases our freedom as Americans. If private citizens do the work of the government, then the government is not needed and therefore will shrink in size, leading to an increase in freedom for all. This is where we lament the fact that the church has not been proactive enough to do its duty of social justice in this country. Third, action is everything. Most fiscal conservatives seem content to do nothing about the country and sit back and let the politicians get the job done. This is the same attitude that people have toward the liberals: let the government do it, and we would do well to know that this leads to nothing good. Even worse, this attitude is deadly in your spiritual life. To just let go and let God deal with the sin in your life and do nothing to combat it or work out your salvation in fear and trembling is not smart. So there you have it. The moral is: those who call for less government need to do something about it. We would do well to remember that.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Good point about how wealthy conservatives who call for the end of welfare should be the ones to contribute to charity and the poor. But the fact is, that would probably never happen. They essentially want to shrink the government in effect to lower taxes, and they are not going to take that money and give it away. That's just how most rich people are. They didn't become rich by giving money away. I'm not saying they're bad for not giving their money to those less fortunate, but at least with a larger government with welfare and other social programs people who need help will receive it. Something as important as making sure that people have the necessities of life shouldn't be given over to individuals... Most people would that saved tax money to buy something for themselves rather than to give it away.