Friday, April 3, 2009

Divine Child Abuse?

I think I angered some liberals the other day. I was at a lecture on theology, being delivered by one of the foremost scholars in Biblical criticism who is currently alive. The lecture was on the New Perspective on Paul. For those of you who don’t what that is, it is basically just a position that revises the context of Paul’s writings and letters. My pastoral understanding of the New Perspective is that is defines salvation as not justification by faith from sins, but as inclusion in God’s community.

This is tricky, because salvation does include inclusion and participation in the community of believers, but only on the basis that we are saved from our individual sins (which is what the New Perspective totally misses). So I asked the lecturer during the Q&A session what was the purpose of Christ’s death, if He did not come to save us from our sins? I insinuated that the purpose of Jesus’s death was substituionary, in that he died as a sacrifice to in our place to appease the wrath of God. The lecturer answered that Jesus died out of His great love, but not as a sacrifice. Immediately, the other liberals got up and started noting in their questions that Jesus did not die as a sacrifice. I think I upset them a little bit.

One of the main criticisms of the substituionary atonement (the idea that Christ died for our sins) model is that it is “divine child abuse.” How could a good God send His Son into the world, only to slay Him as a propitiation, when He could have just easily turned the other cheek and forgiven us? I mean, c’mon! God is so big that He didn’t have to die for our sins, right? Wrong! That view of life suggests an incomplete view of sin and of God. Liberals and the world alike think that sin is something small, something never really harmless, and something that doesn’t require forgiveness. But sin is so big because God is so holy. God is perfect and requires perfection (Matthew 5:48). Any one small unimportant sin keeps us from that standard (James 2:10). The only way we can keep the law and become justified is through Christ’s righteousness. The only way we can get Christ’s righteousness is through His death as a sacrifice. If there had been another way, God would have taken Christ’s cup from Him in the garden of Gethsemane.

The bottom line here is that if Christ did not die as a sacrifice, then why in the world did He die? To be our example? To show His love? Because He was a victim of a ruthless political system? Neither of these by themselves, nor any other explanation, makes any sense. Even worse, these views on Christ’s death represent the real divine child abuse. If Jesus didn’t have to die to save us, then why did God make Him die and go through all that pain, suffering, and agony? That is true divine child abuse. We would do well to remember that.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Good fill someone in on and this post helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you as your information.